Tuesday, July 21, 2020

February 2014 Interview by Dr. Gary Chimes

Below is Gary Chimes MD's unfinished online interview of me for his blog back in 2014. We both thought that there were some interesting things in here after  i dug it up and that is why i'm sharing it. Enjoy this moment from history

-gautam




Gary:

For our next feature, I'm delighted to have Dr. Gautam Malhotra. Gautam is currently a physician working for the Veterans Administration (VA) system in East Orange, New Jersey. 

 

Gautam, like to start in reminiscing about one of the great experiences of my medical career. When I was a senior resident and you were in your first year as an attending, we had a few months where we commuted together to work

 

I can't tell you enough how much I love that experience. On the 30-minute ride into and from work we engaged as friends, discussing life and our philosophy as physicians. In between those commuting hours I worked underneath you as a mentee learning about your thought process as you're coming into your own as a physician. I wonder if you have any thoughts about that experience?

 

Gautam: Thanks for inviting me to be a part of your blog. Most physicians, who stay where they trained, grapple with an unwelcome transition period. You are suddenly thrust into the role of responsibility while everyone still sees the same person they knew as a trainee. I had little difficulty with this because of the incredible support of your/senior class and my attendings/mentors. Being able to discuss with you definitely helped me build my confidence. 

 

Gary: One of the formative experiences of my career as a physician occurred during those two months. We had seen a patient with a hand injury, and neither of us had seen anything like it before

 

We both stepped out of the room for a few moments to discuss the differential diagnosis process that I discussed elsewhere on my blog (http://lakewass.blogspot.com/2014/01/differential-diagnosis-understanding.html).  We went through the list of the different things that the injury could be, and concluded through a deductive process that it had to be a volar plate injury to the metacarpal joint in the hand

 

It was such a useful experience, because I realized that we're often going to be confronted with things that we haven't seen before, but if we trusted the methods,  we'd  still be able to help our patients

 

Do you still approach patients this way?

 

Gautam: Essentially yes. I still entertain a larger differential than is probably needed, but I'm now more likely than before to ask myself if the specific diagnosis matters. For example, I may not be able to tease out the specific rotator cuff tendon that is involved in a patient's shoulder pain. However, if it's not crucial to the next step in decision making I may go ahead with the next step without a pure label for the condition. 

 

Gary:  That’s a great point, and I agree, but may not be intuitive to many patients.  Would you please elaborate more on why sometimes the diagnosis does not matter, and how we can help focus our patients on things like functional goals that may be more important to them?   I find that the concept of function, rather than cure, can be confusing to patients.

 

Gautam:


--------

Gary: One of the things that you and I have talked about a lot in the past decade is how we will go through these ebbs and flows where we feel like geniuses, and other periods where we feel senses of inadequacy about how little we know. One of my favorite expressions of yours is that "we need to engage in a constant battle against complacency."  Can you elaborate on that?

 

Gautam: As a resident, I always felt like a failure no matter what. I guess my goal was to be intelligent, get the diagnosis right, get the management right, get the patient better, get the patient to like me, get the residents to like me, get the attending physicians to like me, the nurses, custodians etc...

 

No matter what (for obvious reasons) I couldn't accomplish all of this. So instead, I decided to change my goal to the one you stated. It made things very clear for me. At the decisive moment when a choice needed to be made, I asked myself if I could at all interpret what I'm doing or saying as complacency. I think I made better choices as a result.

 

It gets to the heart of professionalism. A professional, in this setting, is someone who offers the same level of service in all situations. So that requires figuring out a system and being systematic. I'm sure this can apply to any field. It's just what I did and I'm telling you because you asked. 

 

One example these days is, when I'm finishing up an encounter with a patient, I ask myself if I'm missing anything. But I do it a slightly different way. I ask myself the following questions:

 

What would my mentors say about this case? 

What would I do differently if this patient was a lawyer? My mother? 

What would I say if this were a board exam question? 

What if this person had more money? No money?

 

Sometimes those answers take me into a whole other zone of thinking which can benefit the patient. It gets me outside of my little box.

 

 

Gary: One thing you've discussed with me in the past is your frustration with the sources of knowledge that are currently used for guiding medical decisions, including peer-reviewed journals and textbooks. I've certainly been part of the problem, as I learned the hard way that I am not a particularly good editor.  Expand on your thoughts here.

 

Gautam: I don't know that I agree with your assessment of yourself as an editor. In answer to your question, I have been frustrated by the glut of publications coming out in our field. I'm not sure they're offering anything more than anything already on the market, and, I am suspicious of the level of scrutiny and critique that their manuscripts are subjected to. I have written chapters for books and for peer-reviewed medical journals.

 

The latter typically provide much harsher critique because they are subjected to a few levels of it. In the case of the textbooks, one or two editors are asked to take on a LOT of chapters. With the deadlines that are provided by publishers, it may be difficult to fact check everything and it may not be welcomed to critique as much. I think this is something we all start to realize as we expose ourselves to more of them over the years.

 

This issue is no different in other media. For example, reputable magazines and newspapers are giving way to blogs. The former needed a budget to go fact checking while the blogger can write whatever they want without it. 

 

Gary: I agree with your assessment for the most part, although I am probably more critical of peer-reviewed journal articles than you are, or at least the way that they are used.  While the editing process is more thorough than some other forms of editing, there are still enormous biases in terms of which topics have funding for authors, and it’s still easier to publish on a topic that agrees with a consensus view than on something truly controversial.

 

I personally think that knowledge needs to move in the direction of a combination of both research, polling, and sophisticated aggregators, like the FiveThirtyEight blog (http://fivethirtyeight.com/).   I think one of the problems with the way information is currently assessed in medicine is that we don’t put enough thought into how information is then translated into decision making, and medical literature is frequently cited by people without the appropriate skill set to interpret the context of that information.  I think that is one of the essential roles of physicians- using our experience, decades of education, and empathy to interpret all forms of medical literature.  Thoughts?

 

Gautam:


 

---------

Gary: On another topic, it's been six years since our mutual friend Jim McLean passed away[GC4] . I know that this has affected both of us a lot, both on a personal level, but also in terms of how much influence he had on both of us in terms of the way we practice medicine.  I'd like to hear more about what you been thinking about the past six years.

 

Gautam: In reference to Jim, he and I were the unlikeliest of friends. But I would count him as one of my best friends in life. I most miss being able to call him up for almost any topic. I feel like we fueled each other in ways that I will probably never find again. His approach to almost every problem was disciplined tenacity. He usually didn't take no for an answer unless it was accompanied by a new piece of practical information. Otherwise, elbow grease got it done. I don't know that he affected the way I practice medicine. He influenced how I practice life.

 

I have been meeting annually with his brother and hearing more about his past and how it made him the man he became. Jim would make a decision that he wanted something, figured out what it would take to do it, and then amplified the doing with a discipline that most of us can't comprehend. With his loss and that of Scott Nadler, it's just hard to imagine how much better our world could have been.

 

Gary: You raise some great points.  I had an expression I used to say about our mutual mentor Steve Kirshblum, that “he was an easy person to admire, and hard to emulate,” because his particular combination of wonderful characteristics was impossible to copy, and I feel the same way about Jim.   That said, that’s not the point.   Medicine, and life, is best served when you are the best possible Gautam Malhotra, which you are better at being than anyone else.  I think you’ve been doing an admirable job optimizing yourself.  It’s a process, not a destination.

 

Gautam:


 

Gary: One of the things that Jim and I benefited from were educational sheets that you created as a resident to help teach yourself and others.  Amongst other things, Jim modeled his Electrodiagnostic educational sheets off of these, which eventually formed the basis of the book we edited in his honor (xxx link).   Can you share your perspectives on how the education sheets you created became the genesis for how you approach patients today?

Gautam: Honestly, that was my way of addressing my complacency. Residents need to be encouraged to read. Those sheets were my notes on what I read and I happened to type them up. Back then no one typed things up like that. Now it's virtually ubiquitous. I still remember the information in those sheets pretty much the way they were. So I encourage all residents to do the same for themselves. 

 

Gary: another of my favorite Gautam-isms is your realization that "to understand how to think outside of the box, you first have to know what is inside of the box looks like". Tell me more

 

Gautam: essentially, it's another plea to read[

 

 

 

Gary: I think you have some unique perspectives because both of your parents are psychiatrists, and therefore you understand the impact of mental health on multiple aspects of the healthcare system, particularly musculoskeletal conditions

 

As a healthcare system, how do we overcome the barriers to prevent people from engaging the mental health system as part of their overall wellness program?

 

Gautam: This is a very interesting question. I couldn't have anticipated it. It's not something I get asked a lot. You're half right. My father AND my mother are psychiatrists. [GC8] My dinner conversation included aspects of the healthcare system, mental health, and doing the right thing in these settings throughout my childhood.

 

Today, I think there is a lot less stigma associated with mental health than in the 70's or 80's. However, it is still brushed under the rug in most situations where it is needed the most. I would say that psychiatrists and physiatrsts can potentially work very well together as a team. There is a huge cognitive-behavioral component to our conservative treatments. One thing the physiatrist can do is to explicitly discuss the role of mental health in the recovery from pain or functional impairment. Bringing it up in the context of the treatment rather than the diagnosis is often better accepted by most people.  If you can find a good psychiatrist in your community, befriend them and get to know them. Have them get to know you. It's important that we say "I'm not saying that it's all in your head....but your head does influence the way you process information and signals from your body." Osteopaths treat the mind, body, and spirit together. It makes sense. We should do that too. 

 

Gary:  I think you raise some wonderful points, but I think there are a few barriers that come up that legitimately prevent patients from engaging the mental health system, and I could use your advice on how to navigate these barriers.

 

One barrier is that patients are legitimately concerned that a label of a mental health condition will have consequences, and they are correct that this can happen.  For example, disability insurance carriers do not make a distinction between the health risks of Bipolar 1 and Bipolar 2, and many of my high functioning Bipolar 2 patients do not want the label of Bipolar 2 in their charts, with a justifiable fear that this will affect their insurability.  So, do you have thoughts on how they can address their health issues while still respecting their privacy.

 

A bigger, and more common, barrier, is a lack of insight regarding their anxiety.  I have often noted that (using back pain as an example) that I have never seen a patient for low back pain- I’ve only seen patients for the anxiety associated with their low back pain.  People have low back pain every day- they only seek the care of a physician when the pain reaches a sufficient threshold that it is impacting their life, which affects their mood and emotional state.  

 

There is nothing wrong with being anxious- patients should feel anxious, and part of our job is addressing their anxiety.  However, there is something wrong when the patient doesn’t own their anxiety.  More damaging is when the patient misattributes their anxiety to their caregiver- the “white coat” phenomenon, and I find this becomes a major barrier that prevents the patients from being good listeners.  They no longer hear what is being said, and instead hear what they feel, which is anxiety.

 

I’d appreciate your thoughts on how we should address both the systemic insurance issues that prevent adequate mental health treatment, and how we can better help patients who are not emotionally ready to own their anxiety.

 

Gautam:

 

Gary: On another topic, you are one of the few doctors I know who works in several different settings simultaneously.  Would you share your perspectives on the different types of care delivery you do, and the strengths/weaknesses of each one

 

Gautam: Within the VA system,  I diagnose and manage the musculoskeletal, pain, and functional needs of all veterans in the state of new jersey. Because my job requires me to service a population's entire physiatric (PM&R) needs, I can't really stop being a generalist. I can't ever superspecialize in just one issue and not see the other issues.

 

For example, one of our mutual mentors Pay Foye has developed a reputation for managing disorders of the coccyx. People come from all around the world to see him for this. I can never do that in the VA system. I don't mind it but it is worth noting. In the VA, I also have the responsibility of doing whatever I need to for the veteran. If an MRI is indicated, I don't have to jump through hoops to get it. If it's not indicated, I don't have to order it for fear of litigation. I spend the time educating them and they usually are fine with my decision. My paycheck is not contingent on how many procedures I do or how many patients I can cram into one hour. Again, I do what's needed. 

 

On the other hand, I do see patients in private practices. Patients can be a bit more demanding about their perceived needs. They can threaten litigation and they can shop around for another doctor who will bend to their will. Most of the time, I have no difficulty educating patients and engaging them in their own management. However, I would be lying if I didn't say that my encounters are affected by financial considerations in this setting. I assumed that when I see a patient with insurance, that their insurance will pay for the service rendered. Many times this is not the case. I can understand the need to ferret out fraud and abuse, but those of us who are not cutting corners should not be penalized for the few. 

 

In response to this, I decided to start performing utilization reviews. Here I am the one who reviews a chart and advises on whether the insurance company should pay for the requested service. Initially I saw myself being the hero to all being reviewed and advocating for the doctor. However, there are a lot of cases where the reasoning and/or documentation is so lackluster, that even I have to agree. Again, this unfortunately translates to those who are doing the job right.

 

Gary:  Most doctors, including me, do not have personal exposure to utilization reviews.  As a treating physician, I find them incredibly obstructionist.  The best case scenario is that I am able to perform a test I ordered, but with 30-200 minutes of my personal or staff time occupied, and that comes with a huge opportunity cost.

 

I also find that my experience on appeals is very much subject to the whims of the reviewers.  I’ve had a few obvious cases that were denied, and I’ve had marginal cases approved (… and I’ve always told the reviewers when I felt the need was marginal).

 

There is one particularly insidious aspect of utilization reviews that I worry about- that the insurance companies may be hiring physicians as a means of influencing their decision making, essentially buying their influence as thought leaders.  For example, we have known for years that pharmaceutical companies have for years hired physicians as “consultants” to speak on their behalf, and how this is a mechanism by which Pharma can pay influential thought leaders (see, for example, http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=130632056).

 

Similarly, I have noticed a pattern where many influential physicians have been hired by insurance companies to perform utilization reviews, and then lo and behold, they start speaking out at national meetings about how physician over-utilization is the main driver of the cost of health care.  First, I don’t think that is true (see http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2010/08/8-reasons-healthcare-costs-rising.html for thoughts on this).  Second, I think it creates an unhealthy shift in priorities for thought leaders, where instead of working with their physician colleagues to help improve care, they are not working for the insurance companies looking for ways to limit care.

 

The most dangerous aspect of this is the substitution of the word “quality” when they really mean “cost containment.”  By denying things like MRIs, SI joint injection- these are not quality measures, they are cost saving measures.  And they aren’t even working on the level of cost savings.  Patients ultimately want to get better, so when there are delays in getting needed treatments, patients shop around.  Unfortunately, in the field of MSK rehab in particular, it often shifts patients into taking opiates, which is the most expensive treatment arm of all, since long term opiate use to manage treatable conditions is expensive and disabling.

 

Thought?

 

Gautam:


 

Gary: What your vision for how you'd like to see health care evolve over the next 5 years

 

Gautam: Non-physician entities are trying to profit from healthcare. They see us as an industry. They want to cut costs by any means necessary. Pretty soon the doctors and the people will manifest the intestinal fortitude to say this is NOT what we want!!

 

The rich already have their advocates in government. What about the rest of us? Will we vote for the same people that are already there and not keeping our best interests in mind? Or are we going to start holding their feet to the fire? The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) was an opportunity for congress to do something wildly new and revolutionary. Instead they hedged on every level. Instead of pushing health care, they pushed health insurance. Those two are not equal.

 

I personally feel we need to move to a “Freemium” model of health care. The free healthcare should be provided by the government by government funded practices for all taxpayers I envision something like the VA. (I wish I personally could go to the VA for my care.) If someone wants to go elsewhere, they can always pay out of pocket (premium). But currently our healthcare system is not governed by the laws of supply and demand. These are uncoupled by the insurance companies. 

 

Gary: On another topic, one of your other passions is music, and I love watching you perform live. You sing with such unbridled passion, and watching you sing is when I feel like I see the real you.

 

One of the things that I think is missing with what I call corporate medicine is at the physicians are being asked to restrain themselves and not act according to their passion and instincts 

 

First off, do you feel this way at all when you practice within the constraints of the system? Second, if you do you think this is a good thing?

 

Gautam: Thanks. I am now an accomplished singer. I was not born with a great voice. I was actually booed off my high school stage twice! Discipline, practice, and attention to detail got me where I am. Our patients expect their doctors to have implemented discipline, rigorous practice and attention to detail when caring for them. Anything else is going back to the complacency thing. Passion is an important component in any endeavor but it has to be tempered. Instincts and intuition are usually the result of gathering informal and subconscious data in a situation. There is a place for these. I don't know how often it should be the main driving force though.

 

I think you might be referring to evidence based medicine. Unfortunately, we don't have a whole lot of evidence in our field. Sure there are a lot publications every month, but most of them do not directly influence our day to day practice. consensus guidelines are important in ensuring that  we, as board certified and licensed physicians, are following some kind of reasoning. However, guidelines are NOT set in stone and should not be set in stone. My time with the utilization reviews reveals that this is how they are taken. Guidelines should be revised often. Our society has to make research a priority and fund it if they want evidence based medicine. So although you can passionately push things for your patients, emotion should not be what drives those encounters.

No comments:

Post a Comment